All Her Fault (2025)
TV show · 2025 · Mystery, Crime · English
Curator score: 5.3/10 (42.8K ratings)
Tagline: All these nice people. Killing each other.
In Chicago, Marissa Irvine arrives at 14 Arthur Avenue, expecting to pick up her young son Milo from his first playdate with a boy at his new school. But the woman who answers the door isn't a mother she recognizes. She isn't the nanny. She doesn't have Milo. And so begins every parent's worst nightmare.
Ratings:
- Curator score: 5.3/10
- IMDb: 7.5/10
- Rotten Tomatoes: 79%
- Metacritic: 63
- TMDB: 8.0/10
Production: Carnival Films, Universal International Studios
Cast: Sarah Snook, Jake Lacy, Sophia Lillis, Michael Peña, Dakota Fanning, Abby Elliott, Jay Ellis, Duke McCloud
Where to watch: Peacock Premium, Peacock Premium Plus
Curator Review
Verdict: A tense, high-concept missing-child thriller with strong hook, efficient pacing, and a reliably watchable ensemble. It should satisfy viewers who like domestic suspense and escalating paranoia, though it leans on familiar genre machinery more than true originality.
Best for: Fans of propulsive mystery thrillers; Viewers who like suburban/domestic suspense; People who enjoy limited-series crime stories with a strong central premise; Audiences drawn to anxious, parent-centered psychological drama
Skip if: You want a highly original or twist-defying mystery; You dislike melodramatic thriller plotting; You prefer character studies over plot-driven suspense; You are tired of stories built around missing children
Overview: All Her Fault is built on a nightmare premise and knows exactly how to use it. The setup is immediate, emotionally legible, and designed for bingeing: a child goes missing, everyone seems suspect, and every answer only deepens the unease. That kind of engine can be very effective when you want a series to move fast and keep pressure on the viewer.
Worth noting: The show’s appeal is less about reinvention than execution. It sits comfortably in the modern prestige-thriller lane, with polished performances and a steady drip of reveals, but it also relies on familiar beats from the domestic suspense playbook. If you like that mode, the compact single-season format is a plus; if you’re looking for something more surprising or psychologically layered, it may feel a little familiar.
Bottom line: Overall, this is a solid recommendation for thriller fans who value momentum and atmosphere over novelty. It should land best as a tense weekend watch rather than a major genre landmark.
Recommended similar titles:
- The Missing (2014 · Curator 7.1/10 (32.7K ratings) · Where to watch: Starz, Philo, Spectrum On Demand)
A grief-soaked, parent-driven mystery that balances investigation with emotional devastation and slow-burn suspense.
- The Undoing (2020 · Curator 4.9/10 (117.8K ratings) · Where to watch: Max)
Glossy, anxiety-fueled domestic thriller with elite cast energy and a central mystery that keeps suspicion shifting.
- Big Little Lies (2017 · Curator 9.3/10 (245.8K ratings) · Where to watch: Max)
Prestige suburban suspense with secrets, lies, and escalating dread around family life and hidden violence.
- Sharp Objects (2018 · Curator 8.0/10 (138.2K ratings) · Where to watch: Max)
Moody, psychologically dense crime storytelling with trauma, family damage, and a haunting small-community atmosphere.
- The Night Of (2016 · Curator 9.0/10 (194.8K ratings) · Where to watch: Pure Flix, Max)
A grim, propulsive limited series that turns a single crisis into a layered, suspenseful character study.
- Mare of Easttown (2021 · Curator 9.3/10 (221.9K ratings) · Where to watch: Max)
A grounded mystery with strong emotional texture, community secrets, and a lead performance that anchors the tension.
- The Sinner (2017 · Curator 8.3/10 (152.9K ratings) · Where to watch: Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads)
Anthology crime drama that leans into psychological mystery, hidden motives, and compulsive reveal structure.
- Top of the Lake (2013 · Curator 5.8/10 (40.1K ratings) · Where to watch: Hulu)
A dark, atmospheric investigation series with unsettling mood, damaged characters, and a strong sense of place.
- Your Honor (2020 · Curator 3.9/10 (81.2K ratings) · Where to watch: fuboTV, Paramount Plus Premium, Spectrum On Demand)
A high-stakes family crisis thriller where one bad decision spirals into escalating danger and moral compromise.
- The Leftovers (2014 · Curator 0.8/10 (1.2K ratings) · Where to watch: Max)
For viewers who want grief, dread, and family trauma pushed into a more ambitious and emotionally resonant register.
- The Stranger (2020 · Curator 0.7/10 (556 ratings) · Where to watch: Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads)
A tightly wound mystery series built on secrets, blackmail, and the collapse of ordinary family life.
- The Flight Attendant (2020 · Curator 7.4/10 (67.5K ratings) · Where to watch: Max)
A sleek, high-energy mystery with paranoia, unreliable perception, and strong binge appeal.
Topics: thriller, mystery, crime drama, domestic suspense, psychological, tense, limited series, bingeable, parental fear, prestige
https://watchlist.tannermartz.com/apple/tv-show/all-her-fault/246386
All Her Fault (2025)
TV show · 2025 · Mystery, Crime · English
Curator score: 5.3/10 (42.8K ratings)
All these nice people. Killing each other.
Overview In Chicago, Marissa Irvine arrives at 14 Arthur Avenue, expecting to pick up her young son Milo from his first playdate with a boy at his new school. But the woman who answers the door isn't a mother she recognizes. She isn't the nanny. She doesn't have Milo. And so begins every parent's worst nightmare.
Ratings
Curator score: 5.3/10
IMDb: 7.5/10
Rotten Tomatoes: 79%
Metacritic: 63
TMDB: 8.0/10
Production Carnival Films, Universal International Studios
Cast Sarah Snook, Jake Lacy, Sophia Lillis, Michael Peña, Dakota Fanning, Abby Elliott, Jay Ellis, Duke McCloud
Where to watch Peacock Premium, Peacock Premium Plus
Curator Review
Verdict
A tense, high-concept missing-child thriller with strong hook, efficient pacing, and a reliably watchable ensemble. It should satisfy viewers who like domestic suspense and escalating paranoia, though it leans on familiar genre machinery more than true originality.
Best for
Fans of propulsive mystery thrillers
Viewers who like suburban/domestic suspense
People who enjoy limited-series crime stories with a strong central premise
Audiences drawn to anxious, parent-centered psychological drama
Skip if
You want a highly original or twist-defying mystery
You dislike melodramatic thriller plotting
You prefer character studies over plot-driven suspense
You are tired of stories built around missing children
Overview
All Her Fault is built on a nightmare premise and knows exactly how to use it. The setup is immediate, emotionally legible, and designed for bingeing: a child goes missing, everyone seems suspect, and every answer only deepens the unease. That kind of engine can be very effective when you want a series to move fast and keep pressure on the viewer.
Worth noting
The show’s appeal is less about reinvention than execution. It sits comfortably in the modern prestige-thriller lane, with polished performances and a steady drip of reveals, but it also relies on familiar beats from the domestic suspense playbook. If you like that mode, the compact single-season format is a plus; if you’re looking for something more surprising or psychologically layered, it may feel a little familiar.
Bottom line
Overall, this is a solid recommendation for thriller fans who value momentum and atmosphere over novelty. It should land best as a tense weekend watch rather than a major genre landmark.
Recommended similar titles
2014 · Curator 7.1/10 (32.7K ratings) · Where to watch: Starz, Philo, Spectrum On Demand
A grief-soaked, parent-driven mystery that balances investigation with emotional devastation and slow-burn suspense.
2020 · Curator 4.9/10 (117.8K ratings) · Where to watch: Max
Glossy, anxiety-fueled domestic thriller with elite cast energy and a central mystery that keeps suspicion shifting.
2017 · Curator 9.3/10 (245.8K ratings) · Where to watch: Max
Prestige suburban suspense with secrets, lies, and escalating dread around family life and hidden violence.
2018 · Curator 8.0/10 (138.2K ratings) · Where to watch: Max
Moody, psychologically dense crime storytelling with trauma, family damage, and a haunting small-community atmosphere.
2016 · Curator 9.0/10 (194.8K ratings) · Where to watch: Pure Flix, Max
A grim, propulsive limited series that turns a single crisis into a layered, suspenseful character study.
2021 · Curator 9.3/10 (221.9K ratings) · Where to watch: Max
A grounded mystery with strong emotional texture, community secrets, and a lead performance that anchors the tension.
2017 · Curator 8.3/10 (152.9K ratings) · Where to watch: Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads
Anthology crime drama that leans into psychological mystery, hidden motives, and compulsive reveal structure.
2013 · Curator 5.8/10 (40.1K ratings) · Where to watch: Hulu
A dark, atmospheric investigation series with unsettling mood, damaged characters, and a strong sense of place.
2020 · Curator 3.9/10 (81.2K ratings) · Where to watch: fuboTV, Paramount Plus Premium, Spectrum On Demand
A high-stakes family crisis thriller where one bad decision spirals into escalating danger and moral compromise.
2014 · Curator 0.8/10 (1.2K ratings) · Where to watch: Max
For viewers who want grief, dread, and family trauma pushed into a more ambitious and emotionally resonant register.
2020 · Curator 0.7/10 (556 ratings) · Where to watch: Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads
A tightly wound mystery series built on secrets, blackmail, and the collapse of ordinary family life.
2020 · Curator 7.4/10 (67.5K ratings) · Where to watch: Max
A sleek, high-energy mystery with paranoia, unreliable perception, and strong binge appeal.
Topics
thriller, mystery, crime drama, domestic suspense, psychological, tense, limited series, bingeable, parental fear, prestige
Open All Her Fault (2025) on Curator TV